At a hearing at the Family Court in Dartford, Robert Sharp has secured the set-aside of divorce orders on grounds of significant procedural irregularity.
Robert acted on behalf of Mrs B, who was unaware that divorce proceedings had been brought against her by her estranged husband.
Robert persuaded the court to set aside both the conditional order and final order. As a result, the woman regained her married status.
Background to the proceedings
The husband served all the divorce papers to Mrs B’s last known address, which was a house where he knew she was not living. He made no attempt to ascertain an address for service or otherwise notify her of the application, despite maintaining contact via WhatsApp during the crucial period.
Then, acting without legal representation, he applied for and secured a final divorce order.
Mrs B was only alerted to the divorce when the husband sought to remove a home rights notice on the family property, which he had hoped to remortgage.
Court hearing
The matter was heard by Deputy District Judge Illsley. At the hearing, Robert argued that:
- the test for whether to set aside a divorce order was 'serious procedural irregularity' as set out in the persuasive authority of Randhawa v Randhawa [2022] EWFC B7 (in which Christopher Stirling acted for the respondent)
- there was no requirement for deliberate fraud to be proved - it was open to the judge to take the decision on the agreed chronology, without engaging in a separate fact-finding hearing as to the respondent’s motive
- the husband’s conduct fell far short of what was reasonable
- even though the parties were planning on divorcing anyway, a divorce profoundly changes someone's legal status and their property rights - in the present case, where no financial remedy proceedings had begun, this was particularly important and the husband was eager to re-mortgage the family home.
DDJ Ilsley agreed with these submissions. She found that although the ‘finality’ of divorce orders was important to maintain faith and trust in the system, permitting a divorce to occur without someone being properly served 'is contrary to public policy.'
Accordingly she set aside both orders, and required the husband to properly serve the papers on Mrs B.
